Here is the YouTube of a debate between Bart Ehrman and the mythicist Robert Price. It's looooong. Here.
What's my prior? I think the mythicists are borderline loons. I have linked History for Atheists before; here is his latest on mythicists. (The “big stick” motive fits Jerry Coyne very well! Not surprisingly I think he's irrational on the topic.)
I recommend Ehrman's book on the topic, Did Jesus Exist?
UPDATE: Oy. I have so far listened to the presentations. Price is incredibly weak. Like the stuff about Q, M, and L is dreadful. Whatever they are they are something, and independent somethings.
UPDATE: Hoo boy. At about 1:25 we get a jaw drawing bit about Zoroastrianism. Price's main point seems to be about Clark Kent and Superman. His argument seems to be that if Superman were real surely someone would have noticed and written about him, and Clark Kent wouldn’t attract disciples. Well, maybe, although it’s a form of argument from silence, but more to the point as Ehrman says, Jesus wasn’t actually Superman, but some followers thought he was. Price's argument is hopeless.
UPDATE: Less interesting at the end, except in a grisly forensic sense. Price has to keep expanding the conspiracy. He seems to end up claiming Paul did not exist either. I wonder how long until Eusebius becomes a myth. But John the Baptist, attested in Josephus, exists ...
No comments:
Post a Comment